Search Results > Property Detail

Casa Mahalo

🌺 Pet Friendly, Ping Pong Table, Private Heated Pool, Steps to Beach!

Bedrooms: 4

Bathrooms: 3 Full

Sleeps: 12

Poolside ambiance, complete with comfortable lounge chairs—sunlit water and lush palms create a tranquil escape.

View all photos

Slideshow

Virtual Tour

Video Tour

Map

This property has been viewed 58 times in the last 3 days

Select your arrival date

Select your departure date

Reserve your stay

Arrival Date

Departure Date

Rent

${{priceQuote.rent.toFixed(2)}}

Discount

-${{priceQuote.discount.toFixed(2)}}

{{priceQuote.travelInsurance.name}}

${{priceQuote.travelInsurance.amount.toFixed(2)}}

{{priceQuote.damageProtection.name}}

${{priceQuote.damageProtection.amount.toFixed(2)}}

Total

${{priceQuote.bookingTotal.toFixed(2)}}

Initial Payment Due

${{priceQuote.dueNow.toFixed(2)}}

We are unable to obtain current pricing at this time. Please call {{contactPhone}} and one of our specialists will be happy to assist you.

{{priceQuote.errorMsg}} This unit is not available for these dates. Please try selecting new dates or call {{contactPhone}} and one of our specialists will be happy to assist you.

This unit is not available for these dates. Please try selecting new dates or call {{contactPhone}} and one of our specialists will be happy to assist you.

Apply

This promotional code is either invalid or expired.

This promotional code is valid and the discount has been applied.

Exclusive Amenities Include: ↑↓

• Private Heated Pool
• Pool Views on 3rd Story Balcony
• Located In Siesta Key Village
• 2 Minute Walk from Siesta Key Beach
• Private Cabana Room
• Outdoor Refrigerator
• Outdoor Dining and lounge areas
• 1 unit of Duplex Property
• 4 Bedrooms, 3 Full Baths
• 3 King Beds, 1 Queen Bed, 1 Queen Sofa Sleeper, Twin Chair Sofa Sleeper, Twin Roller Bed (Sleeps 12) with linens provided
• Spacious Balcony With seating area
• Private 2 Car Garage
• Free WiFi & 6 HDTV’s
• Regular & Keurig Coffee Maker, Dishwasher, Washer & Dryer, and Kitchen Essentials Provided
• Starter Pack of Toiletry Essentials Included - Shampoo, Conditioner, Hand / Face Soap, Body Lotion, & Makeup Wipes
• Starter Pack of Home Essentials Included - Dish Soap, Dish Sponge, Dishwasher Tablets, Laundry Tablets, & Cleaning Wipes
• Beach Towels, Chairs, Cooler, & Caddy Provided
• Gas Grill
• Enhanced cleaning protocols provided by our CottageClean Team
• Island Shuttle Transportation Available
• Dog-Friendly with a Fee (1 dog up to 25lbs)

Overview ↑↓

Casa Mahalo | Top-Floor Luxe Retreat Steps from Siesta Key Beach

Why You’ll Love This Home
Perched high above the palms, Casa Mahalo delivers an elevated island experience just a 2-minute walk from Siesta Key Beach. This third-floor sanctuary blends tropical elegance with breezy, sunlit spaces—and features a private heated pool and cabana for unforgettable outdoor living.

‍‍ Perfect For
Families, couples, or friends seeking an upscale beach escape with walkable access to Siesta Key Village.

️ Imagine This
Start your day on the oversized balcony with ocean-kissed breezes and a fresh cup of coffee. After a leisurely walk to the powdery white sands of Siesta Key Beach, return for a dip in your private heated pool or relax in the cabana lounge with a chilled drink. Inside, the open-concept kitchen and living area provide a stylish backdrop for group dinners or game nights. When the sun sets, toast to another perfect day under the starry island sky before retreating to your plush king suite for a restful night.

Where You’ll Sleep
• Bedroom 1: King Bed + Twin Chair Sleeper, Ensuite Bath, TV
• Bedroom 2: King Bed, Shared Bath, TV
• Bedroom 3: King Bed, Shared Bath,TV
• Bedroom 4: Queen Bed + Twin Rollaway, Shared Bath, TV
• Extra Sleeping: Queen Sleeper Sofa in Living Room
Total: 4 Bedrooms | 3 Bathrooms | Sleeps up to 12

Explore the Area
• 0.1 miles (2-minute walk) to Siesta Key Beach
• Steps from Siesta Key Village dining, music, and nightlife
• 4.5 miles to Downtown Sarasota for art, culture, and dining
• 6.5 miles to St. Armands Circle for boutique shopping and coastal charm
No car required—everything you need is within walking distance.

⌛ Don’t Wait
Casa Mahalo books quickly! Your stay includes CottageClean™, our 6-hour deep clean and 35-point inspection for a spotless, like-new experience.

Need to Know ↑↓

This home occupies the entire 3rd floor of a luxury duplex. Two garage spaces on the 1st floor (left side only). Shared structure, but private pool and backyard for your unit. The pool is heated November 15 – April 15. This property requires stair access. Contact us for alternatives if mobility is a concern.
Interested in different units in the same building? Book specific units from this complex by following the URLs below:
8 Bedroom Option: The Big Kahuna
4 Bedroom Option: Casa Ohana

Comments
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name*
Email*
Phone
Mobile Phone*
Message*
Please contact me with information regarding Casa Mahalo.
Opt In to SMS Messaging
- By clicking the check box you agree to receive text messages from The Cottages on the Key. These messages will be sent to communicate with you about your inquiry, or reservation, or to market our services to you. Please see our Privacy Policy. Text STOP to opt out | Data rates may apply.
CAPTCHA

Reviews ↑↓

Total reviews: 29

Submit a Review for Casa Mahalo

"*" indicates required fields

Comments

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

How Would You Rate Your Stay?*

★★★★★

★★★★

★★★

★★

★

Rental Review

Your Name*
Enter your name as used on your reservation so we can validate your stay with us. This will NOT display on the website.
Your Email*
Please enter your email address in case we need to contact you. This will NOT display on the website.
Public Information
The fields below may be publicly displayed on our website.
Display Name*
Please enter your name as you wish it to appear on the website. Use initials if you wish privacy.
Review Title*
Enter a short phrase to describe your rental experience.
Arrival Date*Enter the date you checked in for this rental. Select the month, day and year.
- Arrival Date*
  Month
  Day
  Year
This field is hidden when viewing the form
Rating (1-5)*
Select based on the # star rating you would give this property. 5 being the best.
Review*
Leave your comments about this rental property.

We'd love your feedback!

Click here to leave us a Google Review.

Review Date: August 30, 2026

"Great stay in the Casa Mahalo property! Clean, modern furnishings, comfortable beds, and responsive service. My family of 6 ranging in ages from 9-months to 60+ greatly enjoyed the property, the pool, the 5-minute walk to the beach and the fun at Siesta Key Villages just a block from our unit. Our first time to the area and we really enjoyed it.

Reviewed By: therich944

Response from The Cottages on the Key:
Hi there, Thank you so much for your wonderful review! We’re thrilled Casa Mahalo was such a great fit for your family and that everyone enjoyed the clean, comfortable home, pool, and convenient location near both the beach and Siesta Key Village. We’re especially glad your first visit to the area was such a great experience! Thank you for choosing Casa Mahalo, and we hope to welcome your family back for another Siesta Key vacation in the future. Warm regards, Guest Services Team

Review Date: August 29, 2026

Reviewed By: Scott

Review Date: August 12, 2026

"Location is perfect. Right behind Gilligans bar/restaurant. Golf cart place right next door as well. 20-30min drive to Sarasota. Place was very clean, plenty of space for 11 people, service from host is fantastic. Anytime we asked for something we had it done very quickly. The only thing that was not taken care of was the beach cabana (only complaint!). Place is beautiful, pool is a good size, ping pong table, bikes, beach chairs, wagon, about 10-15min walk to beach. Overall 5 stars and worth the stay with the location.

Reviewed By: Rob

Response from The Cottages on the Key:
Hi Rob, Thank you so much for your thoughtful five-star review! We’re thrilled the home provided plenty of room for your group of 11 and that you enjoyed the pool, ping pong table, bikes, beach gear, and fantastic location near the Village. We also truly appreciate your kind words about our team’s quick and responsive service. We’re sorry the beach cabana concern was not resolved during your stay and appreciate you bringing it to our attention. It means so much that, overall, you found the home and location well worth the stay. We hope to welcome your group back again! Warm regards, Guest Services Team

Review Date: July 25, 2026

"Family gathering for wife's Birthday-we love this place as we've been here 3 times & I would especially thank Cottages host Ken for his understanding with our booking.

Reviewed By: Ben

Response from The Cottages on the Key:
Hi Ben, Thank you so much for your wonderful review and for choosing to celebrate your wife's birthday with us! We’re truly honored that you've now stayed with us three times, there’s no greater compliment than welcoming returning guests. We're especially grateful for your kind words about Kenneth. We’ll be sure to share your appreciation with him, as he’ll be delighted to know his understanding and assistance helped make your booking experience a positive one. Thank you again for your continued trust in us. We truly appreciate your loyalty and look forward to welcoming you and your family back for many more special celebrations in the years to come! Warm regards, Guest Services Team

Any questions or needs we had were addressed quickly and professionally.

Review Date: April 30, 2026

"Our group of 8 enjoyed our stay! This house is in a great location on Siesta Key. Just a block from the main street and can easily walk to the store, beach and restaurants. Any questions or needs we had were addressed quickly and professionally.

Reviewed By: Mandi Henderson

The house was great pool was nice

Review Date: March 10, 2026

"The house was great pool was nice and close to everything we very much enjoyed our stay!

Reviewed By: Danicka Holcomb

Great stay and very helpful hosts!

Review Date: January 14, 2026

"Great stay and very helpful hosts! Would stay here again! The only reason for the four stars is that the sun never touched the pool. It was warmed and the host did turn up the heater for us, but our group likes to sun bathe. We did walk to the beach which was literally like 5minutes away to solve this problem. The beds were very comfortable too!

Reviewed By: Sydney Houghton

The house was stocked with everything you needed

Review Date: November 17, 2025

"The location was great. Within walking distance to any shops or restaurants you would want. The host was able to address any issues in a timely manner. The house was stocked with everything you needed from kitchen utensils to beach chairs, umbrellas, and a cart. I would definitely stay again.

Reviewed By: Eddie Gibson

We will be back in the future.

Review Date: September 26, 2025

"From the cupcakes waiting in the fridge on arrival for my birthday weekend trip, to the easy communication and gorgeous, well maintained property, I have nothing but great things to say about this place. The only inconvenience we experienced was the pool being completely empty upon checkin and wasn't filled until an entire day later which was a bummer. Other than that, we will be back in the future.

Reviewed By: Blair Hoover

The host was always available whenever I needed to call during our stay.

Review Date: September 15, 2025

"The place was as represented in the listing. A couple of minor issues that arose were dealt with quickly after being reported. The host was always available whenever I needed to call during our stay. Overall, we were very satisfied and would recommend it.

Reviewed By: Paul Thompson

I would absolutely stay here again!

Review Date: September 5, 2025

"It is such a great home in the most convenient spot! This was my 3rd trip to Siesta Key and by far my favorite location to stay. The property was in great shape, the house was clean, equipped with all the kitchen and beach necessities, and the host was friendly and responsive. I would absolutely stay here again!

Reviewed By: Jessica Mccullough

I have nothing but amazing things to say about our stay!

Review Date: August 29, 2025

"I have nothing but amazing things to say about our stay! The hosts were very responsive and helpful every step of the way. The location is truly perfect. Walkable to all the restaurants and bars and still an easy walk to the beach! The property was clean, beautiful and very comfortable. I would absolutely stay again!

Reviewed By: Brianna Lee

Great option on the budget for the family!!

Review Date: July 15, 2025

"Great option on the budget for the family!!

Reviewed By: Jorge Luis Ruiz

We had a great week at Casa Mahalo and would highly recommend.

Review Date: May 26, 2025

"We had a great week at Casa Mahalo and would highly recommend. We even had an issue with a toilet one day, reached out to the mgmt company and it was fixed within a matter of hours. The house was well stocked with everything you need for the beach. The bikes could use a little TLC- everytime they were Attempted to be used the chains popped off within a matter of minutes but that didn't affect our stay.

Reviewed By: Paige Kruger

Very good location to everything.

Review Date: April 20, 2025

"Nice property a few minor issues that were taken care of immediately. Shower head had low pressure they replaced. One cabinet had screw missing they also fixed asap. Very good location to everything.

Reviewed By: Todd Jagielski

Condo was very clean and it had everything that we needed.

Review Date: December 12, 2024

"Location was excellent. Condo was very clean and it had everything that we needed. The only negative that we had was during checking with gaining access into the condo. However, the “on call” person was very responsive and reset the door keypad for us over the phone. We will definitely book again with the cottages for our future visit.

Reviewed By: Brian Cooke

They were very responsive and the place was clean!

Review Date: November 25, 2024

"The location is unbelievable and walkable to the beach and village. The garage door wasn't working and neither were the pool lights. The code didn't work when we arrived, but after troubleshooting on the phone we were able to get in. They were very responsive and the place was clean!

Reviewed By: Hannah Gardner

Can't say enough about how responsive the management team was (via text and phone) to responding to questions we had.

Review Date: September 9, 2024

"Casa Mahalo / Big Kahuna was just what our group needed to get away from hectic work and school scedule. Siesta key village is a laid back vibe and this house supported that. The pool here was great to come back to after several hrs at the beach. On our last day there, maintenance came to clean up some of the foliage around the pool which was needed because the pool area was slightly too shaded and felt like it increased mosquito activity. House was clean upon arrival, though there were baby ants on the counters when no food was out. Management was very responsive and left kid/pet safe ant spray and liquid ant traps to help us out. Can't say enough about how responsive the management team was (via text and phone) to responding to qurstions we had, even sending someone over the holday weekend, to fix the elevator. Would definitely stay here again given the mgmt. team responsiveness and the central location to the village shops and quick walk to the beach.

Reviewed By: Kelly Salomone

Well maintained private pool.

Review Date: July 31, 2024

"Things didn't start out perfectly. But this is the type of company that you want to do business with. They were quick to listen and quick to help. After my stay, they asked what could have been better and showed me the passion they had for their guests and properties. I appreciated the integrity and communication. Terrific mattresses, amazing location for the village and the beach. Well maintained private pool. A great spot for big families to visit the best beach in N America.

Reviewed By: Aaron Mortensen

The house had tons of room and lots of things to offer.

Review Date: June 27, 2024

"The whole family enjoyed the location and house!! They had a playpen for our granddaughter, but didn't advertise it. The house had tons of room and lots of things to offer.

Reviewed By: Stefanie Park

Book it! It's a great space with high ceilings and a private elevator.

Review Date: May 15, 2024

"Book it! It's a great space with high ceilings and a private elevator. Open floor plan with good size rooms. The kitchen wasn't fully stocked with typical things you need like salt and pepper, but they were responsive and got it to us as quickly as possible. The best part is that it's super walkable to the beach (public beach #2 and #5) and bars and restaurants. There's a grocery store 2 mins away. We'll be back!

Reviewed By: Holly Moradfar

The location is PERFECT

Review Date: February 22, 2024

"I would rate this as a 4.8 if it were an option...The location is PERFECT, behind the main drag with all of the shops and restaurants and one block to beach access. The extras- heated pool, 4 bikes, beach chairs w/wagon to haul everything, W/D, ping pong table, were in good shape and greatly appreciated. That being said, we had several not so minor problems, all of which were handled promptly after notifying the management company. The keyless entry system worked fine on all but the door to get into the unit, fortunately we were able to get in via the elevator! It would have been easy to reprogram it remotely as soon as we spoke with them, but they opted to send a maintenance worker out the next day. When we attempted to use the bikes, we had to have them return to fix all of the seats and handlebars because they were dangerously loose and required tools to tighten. That was quickly resolved, as was the water dispenser in the refrigerator that stopped working on day three (the tap water in Florida is horrible). While working on that, it became apparent that the disposal had a leak, again fixed right away. Overall, it didn’t ruin our vacay, but that was a lot of things to go wrong and I believe in honest reviews and count on that when I am making a decision. I prefer refillable environmentally sustainable toiletries to the starter kits with multiple little plastic bottles in each room, and a soap dish vs leaving the wet bar on the counters to get slimy. Still recommend 100%!

Reviewed By: Amy Harlan

Our stay was wonderful. Great place and great location.

Review Date: October 16, 2023

"Our stay was wonderful. Great place and great location. The one down side is not enough sun on the pool so if you are looking for a shady place then this it.

Reviewed By: Melissa Wilkinson

Review for Casa Mahalo - 5235U

Review Date: March 27, 2023

"Great location!

Reviewed By: Melanie B.

Great stay!

Review Date: March 20, 2023

"A great stay! Awesome location; great communication. Property was very clean / well maintained and stocked with everything we needed. Would definitely return!

Reviewed By: Sylvia Haverty

The Cottage

Review Date: March 2, 2023

"Loved our stay at the cottage. The location cannot be beat, fall out of bed and your in town and a 5 min walk to the beach. House is spotless and the bikes and pool floats were a nice surprise.

Reviewed By: James Coffey

We love The Village side best so we were directly behind Gilligans and the coffee shop so wonderful!

Review Date: August 15, 2022

"Had two great shopping days. And the food was amazing! Just crossed the street and we were in the heart of The Village and could not have been more perfect. SKOB ordered every app on menu and all amazing! The Cottage, Summer House, Bonjour breakfast, etc. Gorgeous pool! Beach close. House so big, pretty and perfect! Top floor so elevator loaded and sent the suitcases in up. Nothing bad to say! Perfect.

Reviewed By: Shellie Bratton

Siesta Key

Review Date: August 3, 2022

"Property was in a great location within walking distance of everything in Siesta Key village. Pool was perfect to come back to after a day at the beach. Property exceeded expectations

Reviewed By: Mark Lindloff

Best trip ever

Review Date: August 2, 2022

"Amazing property and location!

Reviewed By: Chelsea Ellis

Casa Mahalo

🌺 Pet Friendly, Ping Pong Table, Private Heated Pool, Steps to Beach!

View all photos

Exclusive Amenities Include: ↑↓

Overview ↑↓

Need to Know ↑↓

Request Info

Reviews ↑↓

Rental Review

Public Information

We'd love your feedback!

Response from The Cottages on the Key:

Response from The Cottages on the Key:

Response from The Cottages on the Key:

Recommended For You