Everyone knows that if it’s called a Siesta Key water adventure, it’s got to be fishing, and it’s got to be fun! When you visit the barrier islands, good times are guaranteed! Just imagine it: blue water, white sands, picture-perfect beaches for beach fishing in Siesta Key, snorkeling in the morning, fishing in the afternoon, and guaranteed fun all day, every day!
There are tons of incredible fishing spots in Siesta Key near our Siesta Key waterfront rentals, perfect for beginning anglers and experienced pros alike.

Siesta Key Fishing Charets
If you don’t feel comfortable exploring the waters on your own, or it’s your first time trying out Siesta Key fishing, don’t worry. We’re right here to tell you everything you need to know! Learn about charters, on-shore fishing spots, licenses, and more. That way, you’re prepared for your trip to our Siesta Key vacation rentals and don’t forget to check out the local seafood restaurants.
Siesta Key Fishing Charters
New to fishing? Not a problem. There are tons of choices to help you feel comfortable; fishing lessons, fishing charters, tons of fish to catch, and good eating when you are done. It’s a win-win every time! With Sarasota and Roberts Bays on one side and the epic Gulf of Mexico on the other, it’s no wonder that fishing is so popular here. Bring the family and cast your line at one of the beautiful beaches or take a boat ride and bring a picnic on the water. All the great fishing spots in Siesta Key are all year, every year, and you’ll easily find a guide to take you out. Here are a few of our top recommendations for Siesta Key fishing charters.
Reel Tight Fishing Charters
Reel Tight Fishing Charters offers inshore and nearshore fishing charters and specializes in snook, redfish, tarpon, and trout. Dolphin tours and sunset trips are available as well.
Reel Tight Fishing Charters is a place where families are welcome, and smiles are always traded. Fishing here is fun for all ages and skill levels, perfect for a day with the family. Bait, fishing licenses, rods, reels, and tackle are always included.
Owner and captain, fishing expert, and veteran, Matt Fueyo re-established Reel Tight Fishing Charters in 2016. Captain Phil has a very impressive fishing resume and is well-loved by all. Captain Darius is extremely knowledgeable and knows how to take care of people and make sure they are safe and happy. All are veteran captains who are well looked up to by those who know them.
Reel Tight also features fishing lessons! If you love to fish and think you might need to broaden your skills, The Reel Tight classes are what you need. Book a one-on-one experience with their captains to learn everything you need to know about fly fishing. All ages are welcome to sign up for these sessions!
CB’s Saltwater Outfitters
At CB’s Saltwater Outfitters, you’ll find Sarasota fishing charters for inshore and offshore fishing excitement! When you are looking to fish the shallow backcountry waters in and around Sarasota Bay, but you also want to fish the inshore reefs of the Gulf of Mexico, you are in CB’s Saltwater Outfitters country!
Don’t be left telling a story about the one that got away. Select the right fishing charter service and catch the big one. Get veteran guides to make sure your stay in the Siesta Key area is unforgettable. With CB’s, it’s easy to arrange an exciting trip to the shallow water backcountry for snook, redfish, speckled trout, and other species. Alternatively, you can get to the inshore reefs of the Gulf of Mexico for giant tarpon, kingfish, bonito, cobia, jack crevalle, tripletail, and Spanish mackerel, among others. This establishment also offers Fly and Spin fishing for all ages.
Double Nickel Charters
Double Nickel has the state-of-the-art fishing gear you will love! The tackle is new and easy to use, and they feature the latest in electronics. There is absolutely no doubt that you will have the trip of a lifetime! Book the Deep Drop trip with Captain Nick and his crew and experience the finest fishing adventure available anywhere.
Captain Mike, First Mate Colt, and Second Mate Drew are standing by to make your day on the water a memory-making day to remember. Simply put, you’ll have a blast, and you will have a delicious feast later that evening. You’ll be taken to the best spots with the highest chance of a catch, and you’re sure to have tons of fun getting to know your captain and spending quality time with your loved ones.
Chasin Tail Fishing Charters
For the finest inshore fishing adventure, this establishment fishes inshore seasonally for Trout, Redfish, Snook, Black Drum, Sheepshead, Snapper, and other species. A great day of seasonal nearshore fishing can get you pulling in Grouper, Snapper, King Fish, Cobia, Barracuda, and other species. Depending on the season and the length of the offshore trip, you will absolutely catch Grouper, Snapper, Amberjack, King Fish, American Red Snapper, Blackfin Tuna, Cobia, and other reef species.
You’ll find nonstop action when you get out on the water with Chasin Tail Fishing Charters. Captain Alex or Captain Tyler and Nate will get you set up quickly and take care of everything for first-time anglers or veteran casters. You will love the day and really love the fish tacos you will feast upon that night!
Plan Your Visit
Remember, when planning your Siesta Key fishing adventure, be sure to book your home away from home with The Cottages on The Key. Select from our Siesta Key beachfront rentals, Siesta Key vacation rentals, or Siesta Key beach rentals with a pool. You’ll love the results!
Siesta Key Watersports
Siesta Key Watersports has over 28 years in the business, and their professionalism shows it! With the friendliest staff and the best-maintained equipment, all you have to do is relax and have fun fishing. When you get back and head back to the ranch, your feast awaits. After all, isn’t that why we fish?
With this company, you’ll fish all the most popular areas around Siesta Key, and you will love the excitement and the experience of bluewater fishing at its finest. New and experienced anglers alike will have an absolute blast, and you might even come out with a delicious meal!
On Shore Fishing Spots
If you don’t want to head out onto the water, you can still fish! Fishing in Siesta Key Beach is actually quite popular. By all accounts, the best spots for fishing from land are Bay Island Park, Shell Road, Robert’s Bay, any of the Siesta Key beaches, Phillippi Creek, Stickney Point, Point of Rocks, Little Sarasota Bay, and Turtle Beach. Depending on the conditions at the time of the outing, these spots are great for anglers at various times of the year.
Fishing Licenses
Obtaining a license or permit to engage in outdoor activities in Florida is quick and easy. Licenses and permits are available online at GoOutdoorsFlorida.com, in person at a licensed agent or tax collector’s office, by calling toll-free 888-FISH-FLORIDA (888-347-4356), or 888-HUNT-FLORIDA (888-486-8356) and through the Fish/Hunt FL app on Apple and Android devices.
Florida’s statewide range of fishing opportunities provides a need for a variety of license choices. Separate licenses for freshwater and saltwater are available or a combination license. If you plan to target snook, lobster, or tarpon you will need a special permit. All licenses and permits are available at the Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission website or from one of the many license agents throughout the state.
If you’re planning to experience deep-sea fishing in Siesta Key aboard a fishing charter, these establishments will already have a fishing license that covers everyone on board. Those fishing on the beach should research daily catch limits and must have a saltwater fishing license.
Book Your Siesta Key Rental With UsĀ
Experience the epitome of luxury during your stay on Siesta Key with The Cottages on the Key, the unrivaled choice for an exceptional retreat. Whether you seek a romantic escape or a memorable family vacation, immerse yourself in the inviting accommodations that await. Delight in the spacious living areas, fully equipped kitchens, and lavish amenities designed to fulfill your every desire. Prepare to create cherished memories and immerse yourself in unforgettable moments throughout your stay. Start planning your Siesta Key getaway today by exploring our extensive selection of vacation rentals at The Cottages on the Key.
